The nymph molted today (barely an hour ago, actually) and the leg has regrown completely, although it's shorter and paler than the others. Unfortunately, due to a recent accident, I think I'll have to stick him in the freezer.
Somehow, he got trapped under the paper towel I use in the enclosure, and was stuck in a scrunched up position for a while. I removed all items from the cage once I saw and I've been keeping close tabs on the nymph all day, but the ordeal left him crippled, with legs bent incorrectly, a droopy abdomen, and pretty much complete inability to climb, despite many attempts to reach the top of the container.
So far, my nymphs have all chosen the most inopportune moments to molt, and this time was no different. He somehow did this on the bottom of the cage, without losing any of his oddly mangled legs, and even growing one back. His abdomen has been fixed, but he's dragging himself pitifully around the side of the cage, against the wall. He can barely walk.
I mean, I'd heard mantids can die for stupid, random reasons, but I never expected this to happen. I feel terrible about it. Does anyone think there's any chance of recovery? I could take pictures if needed, but I'm pretty sure the freezer is the only way to deal with this. :/