Breeder Feedback

Mantidforum

Help Support Mantidforum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Termite48

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 15, 2010
Messages
1,185
Reaction score
80
Location
Carson, CA
1) Sometimes feedback is about a resale as in the case of quite a few transactions.

2) Sometimes the feedback is not being left when it should because a buyer feels that he/she might get better treatment from the seller in the future, if nothing is stated on the Forum about a bad transaction.

3) Some people are just nice and they do not believe is stating anything that might hurt someone else.

4) This point #4 is the crux of my posting this. It is nice to be kind to someone and not leave negative feedback when there is an honest mistake made. This does not pertain to deliberate attempts to defraud a buyer, knowing that there is little that can be done to get even in the end. Case in point. (hypothetical). Someone orders from a well known member from planet X and the deal is for 10 nymphs with a "live arrival guarantee". If there is nothing limiting the length of the delivery time in so as to negate the warranty after three days (for example), and the nymphs arrive with half dead and half alive, then at least is says that the sender knows how to pack nymphs for a long trip. If, on the other hand, none of them are living, one must wonder if they were living at the time of the packing. So one must draw conclusions. There are enough transactions going on that even someone who should have some negative feedback but does at times get high marks for good service. If this is done in favor of the more influential people, the positive feedback sometimes makes one want to take a chance. I personally do not believe that anyone wants to take such chances as to loose money almost automatically is a certain breeder is used. Sometimes the desire to obtain a rare species offsets the risk. One gets burned and the cycle goes on and on. If there is anyone that would like to add to my observations without calling out any one seller, please do so. There are some really good sellers out there and they are not all on the North American Continent. There are some in Asia, Europe, and perhaps some other areas. Just know that if you are trying a seller for the first time, use the feedback forum and see what others have experienced. If there is enough negative feedback against a given seller, probably you are heading into deep water without a paddle if you proceed.

 
What's your point? People aren't using feedback properly? Sounds like you had a problem and are looking for people to "back you up" on your thoughts. Just leave factual, truthful feedback and be done with it. I don't have a problem with leaving negative feedback, because if it get's to the point of needing to leave it, I will not be dealing with them in the future anyway.

 
The only bad experiences I've had dealing with people was when I attempted to purchase mantises a long time back from random people on the net, before I found this forum. The feedback forum has worked great for me. I have used it to vet all sellers before making a purchase and it has always paid off.

Admittedly, I am not the type to hunt down super new species to the hobby or to try and import from overseas. Since I am not into breeding I rather let other people who are interested in it, start up cultures of new species before I try to pick up said new species as a pet.

 
Not sure what you're going for here. We can't force people to leave feedback.

 
No force is even inferred here. Take it for what it is. I am suggesting that people should be using feedback to help warn others of what might happen. I suggested that if you would like to add to my comments, please do so and not just criticize my post as did two of you above. Read it, think about it and add to it if you have it in you. Otherwise don't, ok! Not enough has been made of some of the activities that have been depicted here in the Forum and in some cases embellished with pictures.

 

Latest posts

Top