Help

Mantidforum

Help Support Mantidforum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
What!!?? "Smell they're food". What evidence do you have of this? Mantids will nibble on dang near anything, and if they determine it's edible THEN they'll grab it. Entomologists have allready run numerous experiments trying to analyze prey recognition for mantids, and smell is one that I've never read about before. Unless this is what you meant as "smell", I have to strongly disagree.

 
What!!?? "Smell they're food". What evidence do you have of this? Mantids will nibble on dang near anything, and if they determine it's edible THEN they'll grab it. Entomologists have allready run numerous experiments trying to analyze prey recognition for mantids, and smell is one that I've never read about before. Unless this is what you meant as "smell", I have to strongly disagree.
Dude, what do you think those two long dangling things sticking from the top of their heads are?

 
What!!?? "Smell they're food". What evidence do you have of this? Mantids will nibble on dang near anything, and if they determine it's edible THEN they'll grab it. Entomologists have allready run numerous experiments trying to analyze prey recognition for mantids, and smell is one that I've never read about before. Unless this is what you meant as "smell", I have to strongly disagree.
No, Mantidlord, he didn't say "smell they're food" (or even "smell their food"), but, "You'll notice the mantid 'smell' the prey first," where the quotation marks indicate "give the appearance of smelling," a fanciful, perhaps, reference to the saccadic head movements which predominate before a strike. I may be misunderstanding you, but you appear to say that the mantis nibbles on its prey before it strikes. Surely the process is the other way around, strike first and then nibble the captured prey?

James: Pulled yer baby right out from under that dingo, now didn't I? Cheers, mate! :D

 
Dude, what do you think those two long dangling things sticking from the top of their heads are?
They're called antennae and I know what they're used for. You said "smell their food" so I had NO idea what the heck you were talking about. But for the record they don't always do this. I've had mantids strike at prey without budging they're antennae and I've even had mantids with no antennae feast on food, granted they were more unsuccessful than others. And when you say smelling, it gave the wrong impression.

@Phillinyuma: thanks for clearing that up for me. When I said they nibble their food before they grab the prey, I meant when hand feeding a scared mantis. If you notice, you can sneak the item to it's mouth, and it will nibble on the food and then grab it. I didn't mean when the mantis is actually hunting. And thanks for the grammar correction.

 
They're called antennae and I know what they're used for. You said "smell their food" so I had NO idea what the heck you were talking about. But for the record they don't always do this. I've had mantids strike at prey without budging they're antennae and I've even had mantids with no antennae feast on food, granted they were more unsuccessful than others. And when you say smelling, it gave the wrong impression.@Phillinyuma: thanks for clearing that up for me. When I said they nibble their food before they grab the prey, I meant when hand feeding a scared mantis. If you notice, you can sneak the item to it's mouth, and it will nibble on the food and then grab it. I didn't mean when the mantis is actually hunting. And thanks for the grammar correction.
I should give you more credit, MantidLord. I apologise. I, like you, am basing my statements on experience &, as far as I can see, Australian mantids wave their antennae before their food before they strike. Although, your comment about antennae-less mantid have more difficulty seizing their prey would seem that they may actually play some part in prey detection.

Just out of curiosity, which entomological studies on prey recognition are you basing your arguments on?

 
I should give you more credit, MantidLord. I apologise. I, like you, am basing my statements on experience &, as far as I can see, Australian mantids wave their antennae before their food before they strike. Although, your comment about antennae-less mantid have more difficulty seizing their prey would seem that they may actually play some part in prey detection.Just out of curiosity, which entomological studies on prey recognition are you basing your arguments on?
No prob James, I should give you more credit as well. I'm basing them off of the works performed and defined in "The Praying Mantids" which is a detailed book authored by many entomologists and scientists. I'm sure you've heard of it. Though I have seen mantids touch prey right before striking, I never knew if it were necessary or not. I guess it would be interesting to find out what role exactly it plays in food recognition/ aquisition.

 

Latest posts

Top