Photo Theft

Mantidforum

Help Support Mantidforum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I chose that particular title, if sensational, in a moment of REaction and to generally stir up some interest in a topic that might directly affect the original works of some members here. I'm less serious about personally persuing Joey than some of us are in defending their positions on the issue.

Still, I do not like to see my photos being used without permission. That is the extent of my personal stake in this issue. It is just a "feeling" that I've now, thanks to everyone's help, vented. Aside from that, as written previously, I had an obligation to get peoples' attention were their photos being used.

Just for fun, imagine if a member here were to assemble a website containing direct written bits and photos from posts on this forum. Perhaps he would it "Love of Mantises". Call it a guess or an implication, but any way you slice it people would be rightfully upset.

I did attempt to leave a message on Joey's video comments area which included a link to the original page of my website that contained the photo, but there was an error in posting that didn't allow even on a second attempt. I might get around to trying again, but more than likely I'll spend my time taking photos of my new mantises (for people to later use at their indiscretion). Because that is what I do love to do! As many of the hobby old-timers will attest, we're here because we love the hobby and you can count on us to be here tomorrow too!

I'm not saying I'm done posting in this particular topic. I just have nothing left to argue. I don't really think of Joey as a criminal. I saw a lot of really great photos in his video that I'd not seen before (from various websites that he stole them from) ;)

Here's a recent example of the kind of requests I LIKE to receive:

From: XXXXXXX

Sent: Tuesday, January 06, 2009 5:09 AM

To: [email protected]

Subject: Bugs in Cyberspace Inquiry

Hello. I work for XXXXXXXX, a publisher in Toronto. We are working on a school textbook about bugs and would like to obtain a vertical photo of a pink orchid mantis for use in our book. The book will be very large and we would need the photo to be hi-res and about 17” tall. Would you have anything available and, if so, what would your fee be?

I look forward to hearing from you.

Thank you.

XXXXXXXX

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I believe he was making a joke ;) , No idea how much they are actually worth, but seeing as they are stolen so easily I doubt it's much.
Thanks, Asa. ;) I thought they might be making a joke about the 4 figures... but I really didn't know. And sometimes I admit I'm gullible enough to believe farfetched things if I don't know better. :rolleyes:

 
I bet the kid just made a image search on google and took all the ones that he thought were cool. I think he was just being a kid and being irrisponsible. At that age i doubt he would know about copyright

and manners. I think the good thing would be to send him a message explaining copyright and how this is theft, and in the future to ask kindly and respect other peoples rights.

 
I remember ages ago i posted a screen shot of a movie on here and that got removed for copyright theft :rolleyes:

 
I think in our trade magazine that the writers, members of the org, get $300 a page, but I could be mistaken on that amount. I would assume a good pic could get a couple hundred, but some folks would probably move on to find a lower price example, but those with the budget probably wouldn't flinch at $500, if the photo really worked for the article.

 
Thanks for the "heads up," Peter. I've had photos and graphics "stolen" (not mantis related) before, and it's disheartening and angers me. Many people just don't know about copyright issues as it pertains to pics on the Web. They see an interesting photo/graphic and think it's OK to use... as it's "on the Web." With so many graphics being uploaded to the Net, the anonymous nature of viewing and being able to use all that's out there, and no required lessons or standardized initiation to rules and or policies (even with small print copyright warnings or labels), it's not an issue that many users even recognize. Of course you also have the ones that do know, and don't care. There is no copyright police. And anything beyond getting the person to remove and stop using your pics/graphics is fruitless or more trouble than it's worth.

And it gets more complicated from there.... fair use, harmless use, not for profit, sharing information, don't know who the copyright owner is or how to contact them to ask for permission.... etc. So even if someone means no harm or tries to do the right thing, it's often not easy. Copying and pasting, and saving and uploading are infinitely much easier to grasp than sorting out the large grey area of Web copyright issues. But that doesn't mean it isn't aggravating when someone uses your stuff without asking! :angry:

If anyone is interested in knowing more about Web copyright protection issues as they pertain to Web photos/graphics and how it affects YOU (and we ALL should know something about it), here's a good explanatory link ;) :

What is Copyright Protection?
Looks like the kid stole 1 of yours katnapper, the one of your ghost mantis before you made it in the avatar

http://ca.youtube.com/watch?v=E3FutQnbfBk&...feature=related

At 0.17

 
Looks like the kid stole 1 of yours katnapper, the one of your ghost mantis before you made it in the avatar http://ca.youtube.com/watch?v=E3FutQnbfBk&...feature=related

At 0.17
Thanks for looking out for me, Emile... I appreciate it! :) The P. paradoxa towards the beginning of his video looks similar, but is not my Superman. He got that pic from someone else! :p Btw.... Superman molted to adult a couple of days ago, and I just took some more pics of him today. Hope to get them up on my blog soon. ;) I'm enjoying him all I can now, as I'll be sending him away for stud duties soon. B)

 
Top